Thursday, May 2, 2013

Bagram 747 crash video & speculation

An incredible, horrifying video has emerged apparently of the 747 cargo plane crash at Bagram Air Force Base in Afghanistan this past Monday.



Early speculation (and it is speculation) has focused on a shift of the cargo inside the plane, which was reportedly carrying several military vehicles. How could some cargo shifting around possibly cause such an utter catastrophe?

Consider this simple model of how an airplane stays under longitudinal (pitch) control:





This is, of course, a vast oversimplification of the Queen of the Skies, but as a model it provides great intuition. Start with CL - the center of lift. This is the point along the airplane's longitudinal axis where lift, the upward force generated by the wing plowing through the air at an angle, is effectively concentrated. If you can imagine the airplane as a seesaw, this is the fulcrum. CL is largely determined by the physical shape of the airplane and the wing's angle of attack.

CG, the center of gravity, is the point where the weight of the airplane is effectively concentrated. In the above diagram, which represents a normal flight condition, CG is located forward of CL. In isolation, this results in a nose-down torque about the CL. To keep the airplane stable, this is counterbalanced by a nose-up torque imposed by the tailplane, the horizontal stabilizer on the tail, which is plowing through the air just like the wing, but at a different angle.

The nose-up torque of the little tailplane can counteract that of the airplane's immense weight, because it's so much farther away from the CL - leverage. That tailplane has a Goldilocks design: large enough to counteract the torque generated by the weight, but also minimizing the additional drag it generates as it plows through the air, and the additional lift needed from the wing to maintain altitude. The pilots' primary flight controls can adjust the torque applied by the tailplane, but only within certain design limits.

Importantly, CG is heavily influenced by the distribution of stuff inside the plane - fuel, people, and cargo. If the CG is too far forward, the tailplane won't be able to supply enough opposing torque to keep the nose up. If the CG is a bit too close to the CL, the tailplane's torque becomes disproportionately large compared to the weight's - the controls will become unusually sensitive, possibly leading to pilot-induced oscillations. If the CG is actually behind (aft of) the CL, the tailplane would have to generate its own sustained lift in order to keep the plane under control - something it was never designed to do. Past a certain point, the airplane would go into an uncontrollable nose-up attitude. This is consistent with what we see in the first few seconds of the video.

During preflight planning, the pilot-in-command is responsible for ensuring that the CG is within the allowable range and will remain so throughout the flight. I do these calculations myself before I fly a little sport plane, assisted by diagrams like these:

(faasafety.gov)

With a 747 freighter, the number-crunching is done by a loadmaster and other staff, with the pilot-in-command reviewing and signing off. In light of this, it's really unlikely that the freighter was initially loaded up with an aft CG; thus, speculation focuses on the possibility that the cargo came loose and shifted aft during takeoff.

What happens then? The nose rises and the primary flight controls are ineffective in lowering it. The uncontrollability actually worsens with the wing's increased angle of attack. Momentum keeps the plane climbing for a while, but it quickly loses speed in this frighteningly steep climb - the engines aren't nearly powerful enough to propel the airplane almost vertically against both its own weight and the drag of the enormous wing and belly now plowing largely forward. What lift the wing still generates then disappears when it stalls. The plane falls, and recovery is impossible with only a thousand or so feet of altitude.

A mere broken tiedown in the cargo hold could have set off this tragic chain reaction. And but for the timing, the results might have been far less disastrous.

~~~

All speculation, but simultaneously fascinating and terrible to contemplate. There are numerous other possible causes and contributing factors, including severe weather in the area at the time, and the steep takeoffs typical at Bagram to avoid potential threats. The investigation will tell.

Recommended reading:


77 comments:

  1. wonderful information, I had come to know about your blog from my friend nandu , hyderabad,i have read atleast 7 posts of yours by now, and let me tell you, your website gives the best and the most interesting information. This is just the kind of information that i had been looking for, i'm already your rss reader now and i would regularly watch out for the new posts, once again hats off to you! Thanks a ton once again, Regards,
    obiee training in hyderebad

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is horrible. Unfortunately, it happens almost every day. Peple should pay more attention to avoid such pityful situations. I dedicated my last road accidents essay to this topic. I think everyone should read it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The most popular is the assignment provided by a team of experts. According to experts, All Assignment Help can prove to be very helpful for developing communication skills. Having Done My Homework

    ReplyDelete
  4. Remarkable post. I enjoyed examining your articles. This is to a great degree a magnificent investigated for me. I have bookmarked it and I am suspecting examining new articles. Chicago referencing

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very informative and well written post! Quite interesting and nice topic chosen for the post. My Assignment Help Au has been a pioneer within the Best Assignment Help online services and within the Australia and different countries ceaselessly for over Seven years. Make an order now for professional work, delivered on time and pure.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The HP printer installation is always required whenever the user purchase the new HP printer. For the installation, you just need to visit the HP Printer site and then need to select the model type of your HP printer. You can also enter your HP Printer Model Number in the search tab. Click on the OK Button. The list of all the drivers will appear in front of you. Download them one by one. Open the downloaded files and give the run command. Click on the Install now button and wait till the install gets complete. Reboot the system and your HP Printer Installation is completed. You can also contact to the HP Support team for further help

    ReplyDelete
  7. When you have bought Canon mg3600 printer, you should do all compulsory things for set up procedure. First of all, you have to do all the right ways for setting up printing machine. We are fully committed of setting up Canon mg3600 wireless setup printing machine in the simple ways. Our printer experts have the great technical skills and extensive technical experience of setting up canon printer in the right ways. Our Canon mg3600 setup process is simplified, and hassle-free, and successful, so you can enjoy the printing services with your printing machine.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dissertation help ireland is one of the most popular assignment in Ireland. Get do my assignment assistance from our experts at cheap cost with high grade in your academic career

    ReplyDelete
  9. Get the assignment help Adelaide from the team of native Australian educational writers. This way, you can alleviate the burden of assignment completion.

    ReplyDelete
  10. If you are still thinking about it, give it a try! Call us at Southwest Airlines Phone Number to your flight tickets right now.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Singaporeassignmenthelp.com work is best quality and truthful. We assure to provide you 100% plagiarism free essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  12. Travel American Airlines Phone Number Get the best moments of travel Adventure plans, leave your trip without any stress, and enjoy the journey with American Contact Number.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Air France Airlines Manage Booking Help Desk can assist you in many ways. Let’s find out!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Just pick up your phones and avail the special facilities on board at our amazing deals and discounts by just calling at United Airlines Phone Number. Hurry up now!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Get cheap air fares or customized air fares on Southwest Airlines booking at Southwest Customer Service, which is accessible 24 hours seven days a year.

    ReplyDelete
  16. We compare all deals, discounts and official airfare before offering you the best deals. You can save up to 40% on American Airlines Cancellation Number.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Don’t waste your precious time in searching flight tickets with best offers, just go to our Etihad Airways Contact Number website and get all the solution of your travel related problems.

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you don’t want to lose the opportunity to travel in luxury at affordable price then dial Spirit Airlines Phone Number and reach to our experts to make your reservation with Spirit Airlines. Our assistance by our professionals are available 24x7 so that you can contact them anytime. So, feel free to contact us anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Feel free to get in touch with us via British Airways Toll Free to get the great deals and offers on your flight tickets and get all your problems and questions resolved in no time. We have a team of experts who are well-trained and always ready with support of your queries.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Grab your deals and discounts with Spirit Airlines. Spirit Airlines offers to travel to your dream vacation at very low price. When you travel with us you will get your flight comfortable with world class facility. So dial Spirit Toll Free Number and grab your offers.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Call at Southwest Airlines Contact Number to book tickets of any Southwest Airlines destination.

    ReplyDelete
  22. We at Allegiant Airlines Customer Service provide 24/7 services and our professionals are all the time ready to respond to your call and provide every possible service you need. We are there to help our customers with our best offers.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Dial Lufthansa Airlines Toll Free Number to get the best solution to your problem. Our experts will carry out the best process to get rid of your particular problem and support you during the action process.

    ReplyDelete
  24. The customer can complain against the flight, costs, takeoff, landing, and so on by connecting with the executives of Allegiant Airlines Toll Free Number.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Assignment Help services will get you chances to connect with online tutors and solve your concerns without any stress. Collect all required information of selected service provider before placing your order.
    My Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you so much for this excellent blog article. Your writing style and the way you have presented your content is awesome. Now I am pretty clear on this topic. If someone needs Assignment Help, then he or she can go to my site to get it. My service is helping students get excellent services in assignment writing. There are several excellent professors who are willing to help at all times. Please feel free to contact me if any help is required.
    Assignment Help Online
    Best Assignment Help
    Assignment Helper
    Assignment Help In USA
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Company
    Assignment Help Experts
    Assignment Help Service
    Online Assignment Help Services

    ReplyDelete
  27. We are the most professional quality-oriented assignment writing help Service providers. Alpha academic assignment help are 100% original and free from plagiarism at very affordable rates. We are available 24*7 to help the students in their academic work. We provide academic help in subjects like Management assignment writing services, accounting assignment writing service, Operations Assignment, Marketing Assignment writing services, Economics Assignment and IT. Our main aim is to provide the best help in academic assignment help to students, which helps them to get good grades in their academic performances.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Get affordable assignment help in Sydney through precise assignment makers and get rid of all your academic duties related to on-time coursework submission.

    My Assignment Helpline | Assignment Help Australia

    ReplyDelete

  29. Great blog! This blog gives the easy tips to travel Nepal. It also helps travelers to book affordable Nepal Tour Packages online. This blog is very helpful for me. Thanks for sharing this valuable blog.
    Nepal Tour Package
    Nepal Tour

    ReplyDelete
  30. office.com/setup : Visit www.office.com/setup login and follow the on-screen instructions to register, login and enter your product key to activate Microsoft office.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Assignment Help Online services are the best way to complete academic papers without hampering your studies. Make the best use of your time using online assignment writing even if you are in the US. Get the support of native academic writers by getting the assistance of online tutors.
    Online Assignment
    help with my assignment
    Help Assignment
    Assignment Help Company

    ReplyDelete
  32. These amazing assignment writers provide excellent Assignment Help, and different kinds of Assignment writing help for the students across Australia, UK, USA, Malaysia and various other countries. Our Fine-tuned Academic writers provide you with the best possible service.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Assignment Work Help provide the
    best accounting assignment writing services and ensure plagiarism free assignments which are prepared according university’s instructions. It can be very disappointing as a student to work really hard throughout your academic quotes only to get average grades.
    accounting assignment help
    accounting assignment help australia
    accounting assignment writing help
    accounting assignment services

    ReplyDelete

  34. Contribute towards the poor to make then free from Hunger

    Are you looking for a way to help the poor? You have come to the right place that allows you to get exciting travel offers for making some contribution. To make the underprivileged free from Hunger, register yourself and get our lockdown offers. If you want to know more about this then connect with us.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Can Cash App transfer failed provide Login and Signup Help

    Installed and downloaded the App but failed to sign up? Does your transaction fail every time? Cash App stopped working all of a sudden? One thing you are needed to do is connect with professionals through Cash App transfer failed. They will help you in coming out of entire issues related with your cash App

    ReplyDelete

  36. Use Cash app customer service phone number to know send money limit?

    Square app shows you all the instructions to make you aware of everything and you can use it to make your work faster. You can only spend $250 in 7 days and $1000 in 30 days period. For more, you have to identify yourself. Use Cash app customer service phone number to acquire more.

    ReplyDelete
  37. HP Support Assistant is a software package that especially has been created to help such users who are facing some technical hiccups while using HP printer at their home or office. Therefore, to enhance the performance of HP printer machine, one has to download this software into their system.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Take chemistry assignment help and overcome all issues of academic writing. Make timely submission of chemistry assignments using experts’ help and meet the due dates without any stress.

    ReplyDelete
  39. If you are attempting to access the company file not present in your computer system, you can seriously experience QuickBooks Error H505. This error code can display, when you want to access that company files which needs some extra configuration. You can choose us as a reliable third party QuickBooks support company. A message will display on the computer screen just by saying that, “This company file is available on another computer system and QuickBooks needs some assistance connecting. Our certified QuickBooks experts have the great skills and extensive experience to deal minor and major issues associated to QuickBooks. Our live QuickBooks team is available round the clock to help you for any issues.

    ReplyDelete
  40. They begin making them an undertaking that is absolutely fascinating and legitimate. This online website dependably utilizes a copyright infringement checker to ensure that the work they pass on is made out of debasement free.
    pay someone to take my online class
    Expository essay
    Do My Homework Online

    ReplyDelete
  41. Assignment help that ensures that you meet the deadline every time. It is important that the assignments are written in a way that all the questions asked by your professor are answered and all the objectives are fulfilled. Our subject experts make sure that we do not deviate from the actual context of the assignment and provide the best possible solution without charging an exorbitant amount. Our fair pricing and discounts make our services even more accessible and the best choice when availing the online assignment help in Australia. We consider it a sign of discipline to meet the deadline and submit top quality work within the designated time limit. The subject experts at assignment work help deliver the required output to meet the expectations of our clients every time and make sure that you get good marks for every assignment.
    best online assignment writing help
    best assignment writing help
    best assignment help australia
    online assignment help
    best assignment help
    assignment help in usa
    assignment work help

    ReplyDelete
  42. Place an order for Assignment Help  in Singapore to access effective academic writing services for your assignment. It is good to connect with experienced writers when things come to obtain high marks.
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online

    ReplyDelete
  43. Take Online Assignment Help and finish your academic documents before the deadlines. Avail of the online academic writing services when you don’t want to lose your marks and degrade your academic performance in any condition. Make your project submission worthy of American universities using expert’s assistance.
    Online Assignment
    help with my assignment
    Assignment Help Service

    ReplyDelete
  44. Wi-Fi protect setup is one of the ways to make a connection between printer and other devices. If you are unable to find and use WPS Pin on your HP printer then get help from experts to find it.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Nice Post...
    Whenever you see printer driver is unavailable error message on your computer screen that means your installed driver gets corrupted or damaged and due to this computer fails to recognize it. By applying some tweaks here and there, you can easily fix this issue as this is the most frequent issue in the world of printing. Anyway, if you want to get rid of this error right away, then you need to dial HP Printer Support Number and get united with well-accomplished professionals. By taking their assistance, you can get cent percent solution of your problem within the promised time frame.
    support.hp.com
    hp.com/support
    www.hp.com/support
    www.support.hp.com

    ReplyDelete
  46. Can Cash App transfer failed provide Login and Signup Help

    Installed and downloaded the App but failed to sign up? Does your transaction fail every time? Cash App stopped working all of a sudden? One thing you are needed to do is connect with professionals through Cash App transfer failed. They will help you in coming out of entire issues related with your cash App

    ReplyDelete
  47. Use Cash app customer service phone number to know send money limit?

    Square app shows you all the instructions to make you aware of everything and you can use it to make your work faster. You can only spend $250 in 7 days and $1000 in 30 days period. For more, you have to identify yourself. Use Cash app customer service phone number to acquire more.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Wow, Great blog and lovely post. The way you have chosen it and the way it is written, it is very good indeed. So please write some more related to this. I am your regular reader and I am also here for my website promotion. Whenever you need to Outlook Support and you want it from experts then contact us from our Outlook Support Phone number or Outlook customer Service Number . The outlook is an email application, which is used to send and receive emails.
    Outlook technical Support Phone Number
    Outlook tech Support Phone Number
    How do I contact outlook by phone?
    Microsoft Outlook Support
    Is there a phone number for Outlook support?
    Microsoft Support

    ReplyDelete
  49. I am a professional academic writer and have more than 5 years of experience in writing student’s assignments. Access my Homework Help when you don’t have ideas on how to compose your academic papers. Browse greatassignmenthelp.com and receive the best academic writing within our budget.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Duplicate transactions in Quicken is one of the most common errors among the users. This error is commonly used by small and mid-sized businesses. Being a user-friendly tool with the amazing features, there can be some issues associated to Quicken transactions. If you are not able to solve Duplicate transactions in quicken, you can talk directly to our live Quicken professionals to get instant help for this issue. We work reliably as a successful third party Quicken support company, and providing live Quicken support services for online Quicken users in very nominal charges. Our live Quicken experts are also comfortably available to provide immediate solutions for any type of errors.
    quicken rental property manager
    delete quicken cloud data
    Quicken Error ol-393-a
    Quicken Print Checks
    quicken-error-code-163
    quicken error code cc-585
    quicken error cc-555

    ReplyDelete
  51. PNJ Sharptech, one of India's quickest Responsive Web design services provider. Our Low cost Web designing services team is fully equipped with the top set of skills, tools, and sources. With appealing graphics and accessible, complete user-friendly navigation our website designers team guarantees that your site not only brings just traffic but also engages and helps you to convert them to clients.

    Also Read:
    Complete Guide About PPC Changes & Trends in 2020

    ReplyDelete
  52. We are the best, reliable and independent third party QuickBooks support company, which is offering live QuickBooks support services for our valued customers. We provide online QuickBooks solutions, if you have any errors with QuickBooks. If you are using QuickBooks payroll support services and facing some problems, our certified QuickBooks advisors are very experienced and fully knowledgeable to rectify QuickBooks payroll errors. As a top-leading and successful third party QuickBooks support company, we offer the best QuickBooks support services and specialized assistance for the frustrated customers. Our live QuickBooks support team is available 24 hour to help you for any type of accounting errors.
    quickbooks update error 15215
    quickbooks update error 15270
    QuickBooks Error 6000
    quickbooks install diagnostic tool
    QuickBooks error 12007
    QuickBooks error 3371

    ReplyDelete
  53. We give the best assistance to your school assignments, piece help, article making, and hypothesis making organizations as per the school rules. Paysomeone to take my homework
    English essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  54. Most of the students face more trouble regard to Translate Chinese To Englishtheir assignment if you are one of those who are looking the same then don't worry just visit singporetranslators.com which is the top website to get rigorous translation at pocket friendly price.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Hallo, teman-teman semua teman kami dari agen indowins ingin menawarkan berbagai jenis permainan dan bonus. whatshapp: +85587536868

    judi online

    ReplyDelete
  56. Hallo, teman-teman semua teman kami dari agen indowins ingin menawarkan berbagai jenis permainan dan bonus. whatshapp: +85587536868

    judi online

    ReplyDelete
  57. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Not sure how to write an essay? Then a service will come to the rescue that includes a wide one at the lowest price and will write you an Essay on any topic whatever you want. https://paramountessays.com/buy-college-essay

    ReplyDelete
  59. Such a great post, thanks for sharing, I am ava watson an accounting assignment help expert. I have worked with several organizations where her key role was to write expert content. Presently, I am leading the content marketing team And provides Assignment help online to students.

    ReplyDelete
  60. We are one of the most reliable, top-leading, and self-determining third party Garmin support provider, which is providing the top-rated and unlimited Garmin support services for all Garmin users. We have many practical experience and full knowledge to deal with minor or major Garmin map update issues smartly.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Hallo, teman-teman semua nya kami dari agen indowins ingin menawarkan berbagai jenis permainan dan bonus. whatshapp : +85587536868

    judi online

    ReplyDelete
  62. Assignment Help services in Ireland will help to meet you with professional academic writers without roaming around the city. Enhance your skills and writing attributes using experts’ assistance by placing your order online in Ireland. 

    ReplyDelete
  63. We are the project team. We provide all types of ignou projects like Ignou mcsp 060 project at minimal prices for ignou students. Our team has more than 50 members with more than 5 years plus of experience. Who work 24x7 to make a unique ignou project. Our projects are plagiarism-free. We are always ready to help students.

    ReplyDelete
  64. The team Southwest Airlines Phone Number are specialist in bookings done for Groups. We ensure your groups gets premium comfort on your travel with affordable deals and that is the reason that makes us the best. Traveling with a group requires everybody to be together! Our experts can book you all at one go and get you all seated together in the aircraft.

    ReplyDelete
  65. We are an international third-party airline service provider that serving this industry for years. Because of our great services and excellent support, thousands of flyers from all around the world called Sun Country Airlines Phone Number already to book their tickets.

    ReplyDelete
  66. lufthansa airlines offers best of its services to all its travellers no matter they are traveling in economy, first, or business class. we are available for all our fliers 24x7. for assistance, call us at our toll-free lufthansa phone number.

    ReplyDelete
  67. You feel marriage is the wrong decision of your life and you are not happy with your marriage life and looking for best divorce lawyers in Delhi. Then we are perfect for your divorce case. Why we are perfect for your case because our group is the best lawyers in Dwarka. With more than 10 years plus of experience in this field.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Ask us for help with the Victoria University assignment

    Victoria University in Australia is one of the most popular universities where many students come with their dreams to come true. Thus here we are trying to help students who want detailed description and expert analysis about Victoria University (VU) Melbourne Australia.
    https://www.allassignmenthelp.com/blog/ask-us-for-help-with-victoria-assignment/

    ReplyDelete
  69. Connect with our experts now to get high quality assignment solutions by professional & Secure Highest Grades at a lowest price for Assignments online.
    Java Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  70. When I give a suitable command to my printing machine for printing the documents in the colors, my Printer won’t print color. I am applying my command to my printing machine for printing in the colors, my printing machine is showing some technical faults.

    ReplyDelete
  71. This is very much great and hope fully nice blog. Every body can easily found her need able information. I visited first time but I found many use full article. write my essay for me cheap

    ReplyDelete